Homemade Extracts: Vanilla, Almond, Lemon and Peppermint

Homemade extracts are one of my favorite “from scratch” pantry projects, because they take about ten minutes of work and then the jars do the rest while they sit in the cupboard.

With one bottle of vodka, a few vanilla beans, a handful of almonds, a couple of lemons and some peppermint from the garden, you can make four homemade extracts that taste better than store-bought, cost less, and turn into a beautiful handmade gift set for Christmas.

Disclaimer

This post contains affiliate links. This means we may earn a commission should you choose to sign up for a program or make a purchase using these links. There is no added cost to you but your purchase through these links helps support our content! Not to worry- I truly believe in and/or use everything I promote! As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We also utilize advertisements on many of our articles. This is simply a way to help support all the work we do here at Wild N Free Farms, without adding any extra cost to our readers. Check out our disclaimer and disclosure page for more details.

As someone who believes in practical self-reliance, I love anything that keeps a little more of our kitchen in our own hands. In this post, you’ll learn what you need to get started, the simple ratios for homemade vanilla, almond, lemon and peppermint extracts, how long each one needs to steep (and which ones will be ready by Christmas), plus how to bottle them up as a gift set.

homemade extracts

Why Make Homemade Extracts?

  • They Save Money: Real vanilla extract is expensive at the store. A batch of homemade vanilla costs a fraction of that per ounce, and you can keep topping it off for years.
  • You Know What’s in Them: Many store-bought “flavorings” contain imitation flavor, corn syrup or coloring. Yours will be just the real ingredient and alcohol.
  • They Use What You Grow: Peppermint and lemon extract are a wonderful way to put the herb garden and the fruit bowl to work.
  • They Make Gorgeous Gifts: A little row of amber bottles with handwritten tags is a thoughtful gift that friends and family actually use.

Want the deep dive on vanilla? Check out our Homemade Vanilla Extract guide for picking beans, choosing your alcohol and topping off your bottle!

What You Need to Make Homemade Extracts

Alcohol

Plain 80-proof vodka is the best all-purpose choice because it’s neutral and lets the flavor shine. Vanilla is also lovely in bourbon, rum or brandy. You don’t need top-shelf liquor, but skip the very cheapest bottle with a harsh smell. For reference, the FDA standard for store-bought vanilla extract is at least 35% alcohol, so 80-proof (40%) spirits are right where you want to be.

Jars and Bottles

Steep each extract in a clean pint or half-pint mason jar, then strain into dark bottles to store and give. I like these 4-ounce amber Boston round bottles. They come in a 12-pack with caps, a funnel and labels, and the amber glass protects your extracts from light.

Alcohol-Free Option

If you’d rather skip the alcohol, you can steep in food-grade vegetable glycerin mixed with a little water (about 3 parts glycerin to 1 part water). It makes a sweeter, milder extract that takes longer to steep and keeps for a shorter time (plan on about a year), so I still reach for vodka for most of mine.

sourdough cranberry nut bread

Your One Stop For Sourdough

homemade instant pot yogurt

Farm To Table recipes you’ll love!

Want More Homestead Inspired Recipes?

Check out our Recipe Index for delicious creations!

How to Make Homemade Vanilla Extract

Ratio: 6 vanilla beans per 1 cup (8 ounces) of vodka.

Split each bean lengthwise with a sharp knife to expose the tiny seeds, then cut them in half if they’re taller than your jar. Drop them in, cover completely with vodka, cap tightly and shake. Grade B “extract grade” beans are perfect here and much cheaper than the glossy grade A beans. I like this 25-pack of organic Madagascar grade B vanilla beans, which is enough for about four cups of extract.

Steep time: At least 8 weeks, shaking once a week. It keeps getting richer for 6 to 12 months, and you can leave the beans right in the bottle.

How to Make Homemade Almond Extract

Ratio: 1/2 cup raw almonds per 1 cup of vodka.

Blanch the almonds first: drop them in boiling water for 1 minute, drain, rinse with cold water and squeeze them out of their skins. Roughly chop them, add them to a jar and cover with vodka.

Steep time: 6 to 8 weeks, shaking every few days at first, then weekly. Strain out the almonds when it tastes the way you like.

An honest note: Homemade almond extract made with sweet almonds is softer and nuttier than the strong “cherry-almond” flavor of store-bought. That sharp flavor comes from bitter almond oil. Please don’t try to copy it at home with bitter almonds or apricot kernels. They contain compounds that can release cyanide. Sweet almonds are the safe way to go. Since this one contains nuts, label it clearly for anyone with nut allergies.

homemade vanilla, lemon, almond and peppermint extracts steeping in mason jars

How to Make Homemade Lemon Extract

Ratio: Zest of 3 lemons per 1 cup of vodka.

Scrub organic lemons well. Using a Microplane zester or a vegetable peeler, remove only the bright yellow zest and leave the white pith behind, because the pith makes it bitter. Add the zest to a jar, cover with vodka and shake.

Steep time: About 4 weeks, shaking a few times a week. Strain out the zest for the clearest, longest-keeping extract.

Don’t waste those naked lemons! Juice them for the freezer, or put whole lemons to work with our fermented preserved lemons.

How to Make Homemade Peppermint Extract

Ratio: 1 cup loosely packed fresh peppermint leaves, or 1/3 cup dried, per 1 cup of vodka.

Rinse and pat fresh leaves completely dry, then bruise or roughly tear them to wake up the oils. Pack them in a jar and cover with vodka. No fresh mint this time of year? Dried peppermint works great. I like Frontier Co-op peppermint leaf, and you can dry your own next summer with our guide to drying herbs.

Steep time: 3 to 4 weeks. Strain out the leaves once it’s strong enough, because mint left too long can turn grassy and brown. For a stronger extract, strain and add a fresh batch of leaves for another couple of weeks.

Already love steeping herbs? Check out our Lemon Balm Tincture. It uses the same simple jar-and-shake method!

Homemade Extract Steeping Times at a Glance

Here’s the quick cheat sheet. If you start the week of Thanksgiving, the lemon and peppermint will be ready to bottle before Christmas, and the vanilla and almond make perfect “ready in January” gifts.

ExtractPer 1 Cup VodkaReady InStrain?
Vanilla6 split vanilla beans8+ weeks (best at 6–12 months)No, leave the beans in
Almond1/2 cup blanched, chopped raw almonds6–8 weeksYes
LemonZest of 3 lemonsAbout 4 weeksYes
Peppermint1 cup fresh or 1/3 cup dried leaves3–4 weeksYes

Get The Latest Recipes

Sent straight to your inbox!

Subscribe

* indicates required

How to Turn Homemade Extracts Into a Gift Set

Each 1-cup batch fills two 4-ounce bottles. So if you make one cup of each extract, you’ll have enough for two gift sets of four bottles, one to give and one to keep.

  • Strain and Bottle: Use a small funnel lined with a coffee filter or fine cheesecloth for the almond, lemon and peppermint. For vanilla, tuck a piece of bean into each bottle. It looks beautiful and keeps working.
  • Label Everything: Write the flavor, the date you started it, and “contains alcohol”. Add “contains tree nuts” to the almond.
  • Add a “Ready On” Date: If a bottle is still steeping, write the date it’ll be ready on the tag and add “shake once a week until then”. It’s part of the fun.
  • Package It Up: Nestle the bottles in a small wooden crate or box with paper shred, tie on twine and tags, and tuck in a sprig of pine or a cinnamon stick.
  • Include a Recipe: A handwritten card with a favorite cookie recipe makes it a gift they’ll use right away.
homemade extracts gift set in a wooden crate

Keep the bottles out of reach of little ones. These are made with alcohol and meant for flavoring recipes a few drops or a teaspoon at a time.

How to Store Homemade Extracts

  • Cool, Dark and Tightly Capped: A cupboard away from the stove is perfect. Amber glass helps protect the flavor from light.
  • Shelf Life: Alcohol-based extracts keep for years. Vanilla just keeps getting better. Lemon and peppermint taste brightest in the first year or so, then slowly fade.
  • Top Off Your Vanilla: As you use your vanilla, add a splash more vodka and an occasional fresh bean to keep the bottle going.
  • Glycerin Extracts: Store them cool and dark and use within about a year.

Stay Up To Date

Enter your name and email to subscribe to our weekly newsletter, announements and freebies!

Ways to Use Your Homemade Extracts

  • Vanilla: Cookies, cakes, whipped cream, French toast, homemade ice cream, and a splash in your morning coffee or hot cocoa.
  • Almond: Sugar cookies, cherry pie, scones, granola and frosting.
  • Lemon: Pound cake, blueberry muffins, glazes, salad dressings and lemon bars.
  • Peppermint: Brownies, hot chocolate, homemade candy and Christmas baking, like our Candy Cane Sourdough Bread.

Homemade Extracts (Vanilla, Almond, Lemon and Peppermint)

Four simple homemade extracts made with vodka and real ingredients. They're perfect for your own baking or bottled up as a handmade Christmas gift set.
Prep Time 30 minutes
Steep time 28 days
Serving Size 8 4-oz bottles

Equipment

Ingredients

Vanilla Extract

  • 6 vanilla beans grade B
  • 1 cup 80-proof vodka or bourbon, rum or brandy

Almond Extract

  • 1/2 cup raw sweet almonds
  • 1 cup 80-proof vodka

Lemon Extract

  • 3 organic lemons zest only (yellow part only)
  • 1 cup 80-proof vodka

Peppermint Extract

  • 1 cup fresh peppermint leaves loosely packed (or 1/3 cup dried)
  • 1 cup 80-proof vodka

Instructions

Vanilla

  • Split each vanilla bean lengthwise, cutting in half if needed to fit the jar.
  • Place in a clean jar, cover completely with vodka, cap tightly and shake.
  • Store in a cool, dark place, shaking once a week, for at least 8 weeks. Leave the beans in.

Almond

  • Boil the almonds for 1 minute, drain, rinse in cold water and slip off the skins.
  • Roughly chop, place in a clean jar and cover with vodka. Cap and shake.
  • Steep 6-8 weeks, shaking weekly, then strain.

Lemon

  • Scrub the lemons and remove only the yellow zest (no white pith) with a zester or peeler.
  • Place the zest in a clean jar, cover with vodka, cap and shake.
  • Steep about 4 weeks, shaking a few times a week, then strain.

Peppermint

  • Rinse fresh leaves and dry completely, then bruise or tear them.
  • Pack into a clean jar, cover with vodka, cap and shake.
  • Steep 3-4 weeks, then strain. For a stronger extract, add fresh leaves and steep 2 more weeks.

Bottle

  • Strain through a coffee filter into 4-oz amber bottles using a small funnel. Add a piece of vanilla bean to each vanilla bottle.
  • Label with the flavor, the start date, "contains alcohol", and "contains tree

Notes

Steep time: The steep time ranges from 3 to 8 weeks depending on the extract (lemon and peppermint 3-4 weeks, almond 6-8 weeks, vanilla at least 8 weeks). The custom time field above shows 4 weeks.
Alcohol-free: Use 3 parts food-grade vegetable glycerin to 1 part water. It’s milder and sweeter, takes longer to steep, and should be used within about a year.
Shelf life: Alcohol extracts keep for years in a cool, dark place. Vanilla improves with age; lemon and peppermint are brightest in the first year.
Almond safety: Use sweet almonds only, never bitter almonds or apricot kernels.
Christmas timing: Start by late November for lemon and peppermint. Give vanilla and almond with a “ready on” date tag.
Top off vanilla: Add a splash of vodka and an occasional fresh bean as you use it.

Did you make this recipe? Don’t forget to share with me, @wildnfreefarm on Instagram, Pinterest, or Youtube! Tag us with #wildnfreefarms

Homemade Extracts FAQ

What is the best alcohol for homemade extracts?

Plain 80-proof vodka works for every extract because it’s neutral. For vanilla, bourbon, rum and brandy add their own lovely warmth.

How long do homemade extracts take?

Peppermint takes about 3 to 4 weeks, lemon about 4 weeks, almond 6 to 8 weeks, and vanilla at least 8 weeks (and it’s even better at 6 to 12 months).

Do homemade extracts go bad?

Alcohol-based extracts don’t spoil when stored tightly capped in a cool, dark place. Vanilla gets better with age, while lemon and peppermint slowly lose their brightness after about a year. Glycerin extracts are best used within a year.

Can you make extracts without alcohol?

Yes. Use food-grade vegetable glycerin mixed with a little water. The extract will be sweeter and milder, and it takes longer to steep.

Why doesn’t my homemade almond extract taste like store-bought?

Store-bought almond extract gets its strong flavor from bitter almond oil. Homemade extract made with sweet almonds is milder and nuttier, and it’s the safe way to make it at home.

Will homemade extracts be ready for Christmas?

Peppermint and lemon will be if you start them by late November. Vanilla and almond need longer, so give them with a “ready on” date on the tag.

Did you try this recipe?
Share your creation with us on Instagram @wildnfreefarm or tag us with #wildnfreefarms

A Pantry Full of Homemade Flavor

There’s something so satisfying about reaching into the cupboard for a bottle you made yourself. These homemade extracts are simple, frugal and a little bit magical. And when you hand someone a row of them tied up in twine, you’re giving them a piece of your homestead.

Steep it. Bottle it. Share it.

Looking for more pantry projects? Check out our Kitchen Staples recipes for more homemade basics!

Sources

homemade extracts gift set

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating